Sunday, May 31, 2020

Sacrificing Systemic Change to Let the Buildings Burn




by Dawn Irons, M.A., LPC-S

I have found myself getting lost inside my head these past few days since the horrific murder of George Floyd. I have thoughts, feelings, and anger that burns deep, right along many in our country, about the unjust actions of a few corrupt cops. My perspective comes from being in an interracial relationship with my husband for 30 years. I have raised three African American children, who always remind me that I am the “white and nerdy” member of our family. I’m not going to lie, that wasn’t as funny to me as it was to them. It still stings a little.

As the riots began to take place, and I voiced my frustration that this will solve absolutely nothing. I had several friends (of all colors of the rainbow), and even extended family tell me that I needed to stay quiet because “no one needs to hear your thoughts on oppression when you are sitting in a place of privilege.” They said I am not “woke.” So, I pondered on these thoughts a bit more. I shared with my black husband my frustration with these riots. I have spent the last ten years of my life as a mental health advocate and working with people from all walks of life. I have worked with all kinds of races, religions, the LGBT community, and people with gender confusion. So, I know a thing or two about oppression. They tell me I should have no voice in this because I sit in a place of privilege. I say that because I have the privilege of my education and training in mental health issues, working with the oppressed, and 30-years’ experience of being integrated into a black family that I feel compelled to speak. So, excuse me as I step right up to the microphone. I have something to say.

I find the riots appalling. Want to know why? No one is talking about police brutality. They are talking about riots and looting, and without even realizing it, George Floyd is not even the issue anymore. Therefore, once again, the oppressed have been silenced, and their righteous anger has been hijacked by the fodder of the media’s unrighteous cause.  And yet again, nothing will change. Nothing. Will you remember the slaughtered man’s name tomorrow? It’s George Floyd, and his life and death matter.

It is true. I don’t know what it is like to be black. I do know what it is like to be a part of a black family for 30 years and counting. Just like many black mothers and wives in this country, I share the same fear when my husband and children engage in American culture. I have the same concerns, and I wonder if they will come home safe due to the simple fact they are black in America.

As an interracially married white woman, I have shared experiences with my husband that most white women will never experience. Among these experiences include:
·      Having a drunk student from college harass and follow us on campus singing Ebony and Ivory at the top of their lungs
·      Having the black campus officer approach us and let my then-boyfriend know he had “outgrown his color” because we were both very visible in campus leadership. He thought he was helpful. It was not helpful.
·      We received a campus citation for “public display of affection” when Brad hugged me during homecoming weekend, and one of the alumni was offended. I still have that citation.
·      After we had children, we visited a church. We filled out the visitor’s card, and when they passed the plate, they skipped our row altogether. Naively, I thought it had to have been a mistake, so I hand delivered our visitor information to a deacon. We never did receive a letter or acknowledgment of our visit there. We never returned.
·      Another church was considering hiring Brad as their worship leader. They were excited to add diversity to their staff. After the second interview, he was invited to bring the family to the church, lead a worship service, and then we would meet with the deacon board for lunch and a third interview.  It became very icy when Brad arrived with a white wife and three biracial children. It never occurred to us to mention the fact we were interracially married. We sat in silence during the luncheon prepared for us, and no one would speak to us, much less ask any questions. One sole deacon approached us to apologize for how we were being treated.

There is a multitude of stories I could continue to share, but I think you see the point. I may not be black, but I have experienced up close, and personal the deep oppression my husband has endured. These experiences happened to us both, and I was not unaffected by the experiences of my family.

For my young millennial friends and family members who accused me of not being “woke,” I can only say I’ve been woke far longer than you have been alive. Excuse me as I use my privilege to take this issue to a level that will accomplish far more than riots in the streets. I have the privilege of education. I am near completion of my doctoral program that has social change woven through the curriculum. I can research and problem-solve at the academic level. I have the unique position to be able to educate the next generation of social advocates in the social science arenas. I am both a social worker and a professional counselor. I am ready to do something of substance.

If we are truly going to address the issue of police brutality and the disproportionate arrests of people of color, which end in longer prison terms, we will first have to address these issues from a socio-ecological perspective. We need to engage this problem at the personal level, the peer level, the family level, the school level, and the societal/cultural level. Once we analyze the issues through this lens, we have to explore further how to implement an advocacy effort at the individual level, the institutional level, and, ultimately, the policy level. This will require time, energy, and effort. We will multiply this model in a variety of communities because what works in rural west Texas will be different than what will work in New York City.  We will need people to be committed to the role of an advocate. There is a vast difference in being an advocate, and in being an activist.  For a real systemic change, we need advocates, not activists. Please don’t get discouraged in the hard work this will require of you. It will take time, patience, and persistence. It will require you to engage the legislative system.  It will require more of you than you think you can give.

It is for these reasons that I think people don’t become advocates and choose the much easier path of being an activist. Burning a building is so much easier than getting your hands dirty and relentlessly doing the hard work to effect social change at a systemic level.  So, what is it going to be? Riots or systemic change? You can only pick one. You can’t have both because one negates the other. But hey, what do I know? I’m just a white woman who has integrated into a black family for 30 years. I know a thing or two about oppression.